freebirdcapital
Topic MethodUpdated 10/2026

Six steps to your own buy list

Finding, among several thousand stocks, the few that are good and reasonably priced — with a tool for each stage.

6
steps from universe to list
3–5
stocks in the buy zone
72 ÷ r
years to double
What it is about

A buy list is not a list of stocks I like. It is the result of a procedure that filters, out of several thousand companies, the few that are good and reasonably priced — with a price at which I buy and a written rationale. The six steps to get there require no paid services.

1–2 · Profile and screener: several thousand stocks → about 150 3 · Quick test: → about 40 4 · Full rating: → about 12 5 · Fair value: 3–5 in the buy zone 6 · Buy list with limit and thesis Orders of magnitude are illustrative — they vary with the market and valuation level
From the stock universe to the buy list. Each stage has its own tool.

1 · Set the profile

Before any filter is set comes the question of what the portfolio should deliver: current income, capital growth or both. That determines the profile — dividend, value, growth or neutral — and with it the weighting of all later metrics. My own portfolio follows the dividend profile, focused on US companies with a long dividend history.

2 · Filter roughly with a screener

Free online stock screeners filter the universe in seconds. For the dividend profile I set a few hard filters: market cap above $2bn, a dividend yield not far below the risk-free rate, a payout ratio below 75 % of earnings, positive earnings growth over five years and manageable debt. The pre-filter is deliberately coarse: whether free cash flow also covers the dividend is only checked in the full rating. Nothing more is needed at this stage — every additional filter also removes good candidates.

3 · Quick test

The remaining names go through the quick test of the Freebird Rating: nine metrics on growth, return on capital, payout, debt, credit rating and dividend history — quality only, normalised to 55 points. From 40 points a stock moves on, between 32 and 39 only with good reason, below that it is out. The price does not count towards the points: price to fair value and dividend yield are shown alongside. If the dividend yield is below 3 %, it stays on the watch list despite its points. It takes a few minutes per stock and saves the time for the candidates that deserve it.

4 · Full rating

The full rating measures eleven metrics against thresholds for the respective sector and against the current interest-rate level. From 70 % of the maximum, the real analysis begins: business model, competitive position and return on capital. This is where I decide whether I want to own the company. The valuation category shows whether the price roughly fits; the buy price is only set in the next step.

5 · Determine fair value and the buy zone

Only now does price come in. With the fair value calculator I derive a fair value from earnings, growth and an appropriate P/E and deduct a margin of safety. Why this step decides success is shown in The two keys to investment success: the same company returns 8 % a year at a fair price and less than 1 % at twice the price.

The rule of 72

A rule of thumb makes return differences tangible: 72 divided by the annual return gives roughly the number of years in which an amount doubles. At 8 % it is 9 years, at 4 % already 18. Too high an entry price therefore costs not a few percentage points, but years.

6 · Keep the buy list

Every stock on the buy list gets three entries: the price at which I buy, an investment thesis in three sentences and a review date — at the latest with the next quarterly report. The list is short, and that is intended. When a price enters the buy zone, I do not decide anew but only check whether the thesis still holds. How to measure the result later is explained in Measuring portfolio returns.

Next to the buy price sits a second limit, the crash limit: fair value minus 30 %. If a price reaches it, the decision has already been made — I buy more, provided the thesis holds. The plan for a crash is ready in the drawer instead of being made under pressure. A price below the 200-day line and well below the 52-week high is not a signal, only the occasion to check the thesis first.

The link to the process

The six steps are the practical side of the process on the method page: steps 1 to 3 are screening, step 4 analysis, step 5 the decision, step 6 monitoring.

The tool for it

I run steps 3, 5 and 6 in the FBC WatchList: it calculates points, fair value, buy price and crash limit, shows a traffic light for each stock and records thesis, review date and every buy decision. The full rating from step 4 stays in the Freebird Rating.

Own procedure. The rule of 72 approximates compound interest and is sufficiently accurate for returns between about 4 and 12 %.

This article is for information and education only. It is not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Model calculations simplify deliberately; past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.
David Krause
David Krause
Graduate industrial engineer (Dipl.-Wirtschaftsingenieur), 15+ years of costing, cost accounting and plant controlling in manufacturing. Here he asks the same questions from the outside: what does a company earn on its capital, and what may it cost?