A multiple condenses a valuation into one number: quick to calculate, easy to compare. That is exactly the risk. Behind every P/E lie assumptions about growth, risk and interest rates that you cannot see when looking at the number alone. Multiples are tools in a toolbox, not verdicts.
What the P/E measures
Inverse: earnings yield = earnings per share ÷ share price = 1 ÷ P/E
A P/E of 15 means: I pay fifteen times the current annual profit. For a controller the translation is obvious — with constant earnings, the P/E is the payback period in years. What matters is which earnings are meant: last year's, a forecast for next year, reported or adjusted for one-offs. Two P/Es are only comparable if they refer to the same earnings.
Earnings yield: the P/E in percent
Often more telling than the P/E itself is its inverse. The earnings yield can be compared directly with the risk-free rate — and shows how much growth the price already assumes.
With a bond yield of about 5 %, the threshold is a P/E of 20: above it, the share earns less today than the safe bond and must make up the gap through growth. That is not a ban, but a clear question for every valuation: how much growth is already in the price? Where the interest rate in this calculation comes from is covered in the article on the yield curve.
- Earnings grow, the coupon does not. The bond pays the same amount for ten years; a company can grow its earnings with inflation and beyond. An earnings yield slightly below the bond yield therefore does not rule a share out — it only requires the growth to actually arrive.
- Earned is not paid out. What reaches the investor is the dividend and the price gain, not the earnings themselves. The retained part is only worth what the company earns on it — which is what return on invested capital (ROIC) measures.
- Nominal versus real. The direct comparison is known as the “Fed model” and is disputed: the bond yield includes expected inflation, the earnings yield largely does not. In periods of high inflation it therefore makes shares look too expensive. It works as a rough guide, not as a buying rule.
That is why the fair value calculator uses a premium over the rate, a cap at a P/E of 15 and expected growth — not just the reciprocal of the interest rate.
Which earnings? The blended P/E
A P/E on last year's earnings ages with every month; a P/E on the current-year estimate rests on a forecast. A blended P/E combines both: with each month after the fiscal year-end, the earnings base shifts by one twelfth from the last reported figure to the current estimate. Six months after year-end, both count half. The metric thus stays comparable across the year without relying entirely on analyst estimates. The fair value calculator works exactly this way.
Where the 15 comes from: Graham-Dodd, Lynch and FAST Graphs
The 15 goes back to Benjamin Graham and David Dodd. For the defensive investor, Graham set an upper limit of 15 times average earnings in The Intelligent Investor — at that price you acquire about 6.7 % of the purchase price in earnings. For fast-growing companies, Peter Lynch added the rule P/E = growth rate, i.e. a PEG (P/E ÷ growth in %) of 1: a P/E of 20 at 20 % growth counts as fair.
F.A.S.T. Graphs by Chuck Carnevale combine both into the orange line, the value justified by earnings: up to 5 % earnings growth the Graham formula 8.5 + 2 × growth (at most 15), up to 15 % the Graham-Dodd formula (GDF) with a P/E of 15, above that P/E = growth rate (at most 20 in the fair value calculator). Next to it runs a second, blue line: the normal P/E at which the market has usually valued the stock over the period shown — I always use the last 10 years, one full business cycle. Which line applies is the investor's call — the graphs are meant to reveal fair value, not to dictate it. For real estate companies FAST Graphs uses FFO instead of earnings, because depreciation on buildings distorts reported profit.
I adopt this yardstick and add the interest rate: the 15 is a cap, not a floor. When rates are high, the fair P/E falls to 100 ÷ (risk-free rate + premium) — at a 5 % bond yield and a 2.5-point premium to 13.3. The fair value calculator offers every route: rate-linked (my default), GDF 15 / P/E = growth as in FAST Graphs, the normal P/E and a number of your own — and shows the orange and blue lines side by side.
Graham-Dodd (GDF): €5 × 15 = €75.00
Growth formula 1962: €5 × (8.5 + 2 × 8) = €122.50
rate-adjusted 1974: €122.50 × 4.4 ÷ 5.0 = €107.80
for comparison, rate-linked: €5 × 13.3 = €66.67
Why the values are so far apart: the GDF deliberately does not reward growth between 5 and 15 % — it is the cautious yardstick. The growth formula from The Intelligent Investor assumes a P/E of 8.5 for a company with no growth and adds two P/E points per percentage point of growth; it silently assumes the interest rate of its time. Graham therefore adjusted it himself in 1974: times 4.4 (the yield on top-grade corporate bonds when he set up the formula) divided by the current AAA yield. The calculator uses the reference rate in its place. Graham himself called the formula an illustration, not a reliable valuation.
All these rules serve as plausibility checks, not as valuations. They assume the growth continues, and they ignore how much capital it costs. A company growing 10 % that must reinvest every euro it earns is worth less than one achieving the same growth with half — the difference lies in the return on capital.
Where the P/E misleads
- Cyclical companies: the P/E is lowest when earnings peak — often just before they fall. Average earnings over a cycle help here.
- One-off effects: a disposal gain or a write-down distorts annual earnings. Adjust first, then calculate.
- Losses: a negative P/E is meaningless; then only sales or cash-flow measures work.
- Debt: two companies with the same P/E can carry very different risk. Enterprise value to EBIT includes debt.
The other tools in the box
| Multiple | Formula | Useful for |
|---|---|---|
| P/CF | price ÷ operating cash flow per share | high depreciation, when earnings understate cash generation |
| P/S | price ÷ sales per share | loss-making phases and young companies — only with an eye on margin |
| P/B | price ÷ book value per share | banks and asset-heavy businesses; weak with intangible assets |
| EV/EBIT | enterprise value incl. debt ÷ operating profit | comparing differently financed companies |
No multiple suffices on its own. I compare every figure with the company's own history and with direct competitors, and use it as an entry into the question that counts in the end: what future earnings am I paying for with this price?
Foundations: B. Graham: The Intelligent Investor and Security Analysis (original valuation formula, rate-adjusted in 1974 in The Decade 1965–1974); P. Lynch: One Up on Wall Street; C. Carnevale: The Interpretation of the Earnings and Price Correlated F.A.S.T. Graphs; A. Damodaran: The Dark Side of Valuation; bond yield per Federal Reserve H.15 (FRED series DGS10), late October 2026.